Well done.
Well, when I saw this, I instantly went to go play the first one, which I REALLY enjoyed. 5/5 for that beast, way to go.
But anyway, on number 2... Well, pretty much every aspect of the game was perfected. Great graphics, amazingly recorded and edited sound. Though it just didn't have the feel of the first one. Although it was very well done, I don't think you should have included the FPS part. It took away.
I also found that this game was FAR shorter, and FAR easier than it's predecessor. The first one was also a lot more horrifying.
Nonetheless, even if it wasn't as good as the first one, it still definately deserving of 5/5.
Good job.